Gold premiums and spreads
The first time you compare two gold dealers, the choice can look simple. Both have the same one-ounce bar in stock, and one is asking US$20 less. You’re about to close the other tab when it occurs to you to ask what each dealer would pay if you brought the bar back. Now you have two more numbers, and the cheaper bar starts to look a little different.
That second question is easy to overlook when you’re excited about buying your first piece of gold, but it can be the most revealing one you ask. The advertised price tells you what the dealer wants for the bar today. The buyback quote tells you what the dealer would pay you for that same bar today. Put the two side by side and you can see how much of your money goes into the transaction itself, even if the gold price doesn’t move at all.
If you’re new to gold, our Beginner’s guide to gold covers the basics, and Ways to invest in gold sets out the alternatives to owning bullion.
Start with the gold in the bar
Every comparison starts with the value of the gold itself. Suppose the reference spot price is US$4,100 per troy ounce. A bar containing one troy ounce of fine gold then holds US$4,100 worth of metal at that price. If a dealer advertises it for US$4,220, the purchase premium is US$120, or 2.93% above the value of the gold, before any separate charges.
For a smaller bar or a coin, multiply the spot price by the amount of fine gold the product actually contains, measured in troy ounces. That isn’t always the same as its total weight. A 22-carat coin, for example, contains other metals alongside the gold, so check the mint or refiner’s published specifications. This is the same check the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) recommends: multiply the metal’s weight by the spot price and compare the result with the retail price you’re being charged, making sure you’re comparing actual weights and prices.
Why smaller bars cost more per ounce
A premium covers the cost of making and distributing a particular product, plus the dealer’s margin. It also reflects how much buyers want that product at the time. Much of the cost of producing and handling a bar is the same whatever its size, so on a small bar that cost is spread over less gold.
The Perth Mint’s own figures show this clearly. When clients of the Perth Mint Depository convert metal they hold into physical cast bars for delivery or collection, the Mint charges a fabrication premium for each bar. Its September 2026 freight and collection guide lists these charges for gold:
| Perth Mint cast gold bar | Fine gold per bar | Fabrication premium per bar | Works out at, per ounce |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 oz | 1 oz | $145 | $145.00 |
| 5 oz | 5 oz | $525 | $105.00 |
| 10 oz | 9.999 oz | $980 | $98.01 |
| 1 kg | 32.148 oz | $3,000 | $93.32 |
| 400 oz (approx.) | about 400 oz | $3,000 | about $7.50 |
Figures as listed in the Perth Mint guide, which is priced in Australian dollars. Per-ounce figures are CreekRats calculations.
The Mint’s manufacturing charge alone comes to A$145 an ounce on a one-ounce bar, but less than A$8 an ounce on a 400-ounce bar. These charges aren’t a dealer’s full retail premium, but they show why larger bars usually cost less per ounce of gold. They also change over time: the same guide listed the one-ounce bar at A$55 in its January 2024 edition.
The format matters as well. A popular bullion coin can carry a different premium from a plain cast bar containing the same amount of gold, and premiums on every product can widen when demand surges. We look at the reasons in Why gold premiums diverge from spot prices. That’s why it helps to compare the same product across dealers first. Then you can decide whether a different format is worth paying a little more for, perhaps because smaller pieces would let you sell part of your holding later. Our comparison of gold coins and gold bars walks through those trade-offs.
When the cheaper bar costs more to trade
Back to the two offers. Dealer A asks US$4,220 and would buy the bar back for US$4,060. Dealer B asks US$4,200, but its buyback quote is US$4,020. The difference between a dealer’s selling price and its buyback quote is the buy–sell spread: US$160 at Dealer A and US$180 at Dealer B.
As noted earlier, every dealer sets their own spread so it pays to shop around. On top of the spread, allow for anything charged separately on either side of the trade, such as payment, delivery or handling fees.
Both quotes below are hypothetical, for the same one-ounce bar, in US dollars, at the same moment. The example assumes each bar contains one troy ounce of fine gold and uses the same US$4,100 reference price for both.
| What you’re comparing | Dealer A | Dealer B |
|---|---|---|
| Dealer’s selling price | US$4,220 | US$4,200 |
| Purchase premium before separate charges | US$120 (2.93%) | US$100 (2.44%) |
| Dealer’s buyback quote | US$4,060 | US$4,020 |
| Buyback compared with the gold value | US$40 below (0.98%) | US$80 below (1.95%) |
| Buy–sell spread before separate charges | US$160 | US$180 |
| Separate purchase charges | US$20 | US$25 |
| Separate selling charges | US$10 | US$10 |
| Total you’d pay to buy | US$4,240 | US$4,225 |
| Net proceeds if you sold back | US$4,050 | US$4,010 |
| Immediate round-trip cost | US$190 | US$215 |
| Gold price rise needed to break even* | about 4.6% | about 5.2% |
*Assumes you sell back to the same dealer and its buyback quote stays the same distance below the spot price.
Dealer B still puts the bar in your hands for US$15 less. But if you sold each bar straight back to the dealer who supplied it, Dealer B’s round trip would cost US$25 more, and the gold price would need to climb further before you came out ahead. The size of the spread determines how far the price has to rise before you start to make a profit.
If you bought from Dealer B and then sold to Dealer A for its quoted net proceeds, your round-trip cost would fall to US$175, provided Dealer A accepts bullion bought elsewhere on the same terms. That’s worth asking about. You may have more than one place to sell, and each dealer may have its own requirements around condition, packaging and testing.
What to ask before you buy
Ask the dealer for two figures in writing. What would I pay in total for this exact bar, with my chosen payment and delivery method? And what would you pay me for it today, after any deductions? It’s a good idea to get all fees, costs, commissions, and the agreed price in writing before agreeing to a contract. Any dealer that won’t agree to provide this information should be treated as a red flag. It’s also worth asking how the salesperson is paid, because commissions can be built into the spread rather than shown separately.
If you’re shopping around, use the same product, the same fine-gold weight, the same currency and the same time of quote. Two quotes taken hours apart can reflect a change in the gold price or exchange rates as well as a difference between the dealers.
One word of warning. On mainstream bullion, the difference between buying and selling prices is usually a few percent. The CFTC has however reported that some fraudulent dealers have charged spreads of more than 300%. If a quote is far out of line with the value of the gold in the product, walk away.
Selling is part of buying
The same-day comparison measures the cost of a trade at today’s quotes. By the time you sell, the gold price, the dealer’s terms and the buyers available to you may all have changed. Storage and insurance also add to the cost of holding a bar over time, and our guide to buying and storing physical gold covers those costs.
Even if you plan to keep the bar for years, it’s worth asking about selling on the day you buy. You’re still standing at the counter, with time to decide which terms you’re comfortable accepting.
Related reading: Compare gold coins and bars · Read the guide to buying and storing gold · Return to Ways to invest in gold
CreekRats.co | Independent information and education about gold, silver and precious metals. This article is for general educational purposes and does not constitute financial or investment advice.
